Prenatal Testing and High-Risk Pregnancy: The Emotional Weight of Uncertainty

Written By Jess Coleman, Ph.D.

Table of Contents

Prenatal testing is often framed, in the language of obstetric care, as routine. Cell-free fetal DNA screening, first-trimester bloodwork, anatomy scans, amniocentesis — these are described as standard components of contemporary prenatal care, offered to pregnant people across a spectrum of risk profiles, often with the implicit message that they are simply part of what you do when you are pregnant.

For many people, these tests are also a source of significant anxiety. The period of waiting for results, the experience of receiving news that was not expected, the process of living through a pregnancy that has been designated high-risk can all be distressing. If you are navigating prenatal testing, a concerning result, or a pregnancy that has been defined by complication or uncertainty, this post is for you.

The emotional experience of prenatal testing

Prenatal testing encompasses a range of procedures that differ significantly in their invasiveness, their purpose, and the kinds of information they produce. Non-invasive prenatal testing (NIPT), which screens for chromosomal conditions such as trisomy 21 through a maternal blood draw, has become increasingly routine. First-trimester combined screening, anatomy ultrasounds, glucose tolerance testing, and carrier screening are offered across many practices. Amniocentesis and chorionic villus sampling (CVS) — invasive diagnostic procedures that carry a small risk of pregnancy loss — may be offered when screening results suggest elevated risk or when a definitive diagnosis is needed.

Even tests that are physically uncomplicated carry emotional weight. Choosing whether to have testing at all involves implicit decisions about what information a person or couple wants to have — and what they might do with it. The decision to proceed with NIPT is often made before anyone has thought carefully about what an unexpected result would mean, what further testing might follow, or what choices might then be faced. Research finds that most parents who receive unexpected additional findings from expanded NIPT describe the result as shocking and unexpected, even when they consciously opted in to receiving additional information. The emotional impact of results does not always track with what a person anticipated.

For people who are already anxious about the pregnancy — including those with a history of infertility, prior pregnancy loss, or previous complications — prenatal testing can intensify an anxiety that is already present. For those who entered pregnancy without particular concern, a single test result can introduce a level of worry that reorganizes the entire emotional experience of the pregnancy.

Common emotional experiences around prenatal testing include:

  • Anxiety in the days or weeks leading up to a test, often intensifying as the appointment approaches
  • Dread specifically around scans or procedures where news might be delivered — the anatomy scan in particular carries enormous emotional anticipation
  • Difficulty being present during the procedure itself, especially when a sonographer's silence or focused attention signals that something may have been found
  • Acute anxiety in the waiting period between testing and results, which can stretch from days to weeks

None of this is unusual, and none of it reflects poorly on the person experiencing it. Prenatal testing asks people to sit with significant uncertainty about something they care about enormously.

The waiting period: anxiety between testing and results

The period between having a prenatal test and receiving its results is one of the most reliably distressing phases of the entire testing experience. Research on couples awaiting results after high-risk prenatal screening findings consistently documents that participants feel worried and sad upon receiving an elevated-risk result, and that the waiting period involves sustained efforts to manage anxiety that is difficult to contain.

What makes the waiting period so psychologically difficult is not simply that the outcome is unknown. It is that the outcome is unknown and consequential, and that there is essentially nothing the pregnant person or their partner can do to change it or accelerate the resolution. The nervous system is oriented toward action in the face of threat — and when action is not available, it tends to sustain its activation through worry, rumination, and scanning for information that might resolve the uncertainty earlier than the results will.

During this period, people often describe:

  • Intrusive thoughts about worst-case outcomes that are difficult to redirect or dismiss
  • Difficulty concentrating on work, relationships, or daily tasks
  • Alternating between researching the condition in question and needing to avoid all information about it entirely
  • Social withdrawal from people who are unaware of the test or its pending results, combined with reliance on a small number of people who know
  • Difficulty making any plans that assume a particular outcome — neither preparing for a healthy pregnancy to continue, nor allowing themselves to fully anticipate a difficult result
  • A suspended quality to the pregnancy itself, as if normal life and normal anticipation cannot resume until the results arrive

Research describes this experience as existing in "no man's land" — a two-phased process beginning with the initial shock of a potential finding and continuing through uncertain days of waiting that are simultaneously hopeful and dread-laden. Even when results ultimately come back reassuring, the waiting period can create a heightened vigilance that did not fully resolve when the immediate uncertainty did.

When results are unexpected, uncertain, or abnormal

Receiving unexpected news from a prenatal test is one of the more psychologically disorienting experiences of pregnancy. Qualitative research with parents who have received abnormal or uncertain prenatal results consistently documents a sense of being "blindsided" by information they were not prepared to receive, even when they had intellectually understood that testing carries the possibility of a finding.

Part of what makes unexpected results so difficult is that they often do not resolve cleanly into a clear answer. A positive NIPT result is a screening finding, not a diagnosis — it indicates elevated risk, not certainty, and is typically followed by the offer of invasive diagnostic testing (amniocentesis or CVS) to confirm or rule out a chromosomal condition. An abnormal anatomy scan finding may require specialist review, additional imaging, or weeks of monitoring before a clearer picture emerges. Variants of uncertain significance — detected with increasing frequency as testing technologies expand — may describe a genetic finding whose clinical implications are genuinely not yet known.

Research on parents who have received uncertain prenatal genetic results identifies the experience of "uncertainty and unquantifiable risks" as one of the most distressing features of the process: the knowledge that something has been found, combined with the absence of information sufficient to know what it means or what to do about it. Many parents in these situations describe receiving information they feel unprepared to process without adequate support, and feeling overwhelmed by both the emotional weight of the finding and the complexity of the decisions that may follow.

Receiving an unexpected result, or a result of uncertain significance, can generate:

  • Acute shock and disbelief, even when testing was elected specifically to gather information
  • Intense grief for the uncomplicated pregnancy that felt present before the result
  • Fear, which may be specific (about a particular condition and its implications) or more global and diffuse
  • Guilt and self-blame — a search for something that could explain the finding
  • Anger, which may be directed at the healthcare system, at the information itself, or at a situation that feels profoundly unfair
  • An urgent need for more information alongside an inability to absorb additional information while in an acute state of distress
  • A profound sense of isolation from the ordinary world of pregnancy, in which everyone else seems to be proceeding without this weight

Decisions following an abnormal or uncertain result — including whether to pursue invasive diagnostic testing, whether to continue a pregnancy in which a serious condition has been identified, or how to proceed in the absence of a definitive answer — are being made under distress. The medical system often moves quickly after a finding, and parents are expected to absorb complex information and reach consequential decisions at the same time that they are processing distressing information. This is an extraordinarily difficult thing to ask of anyone.

What a high-risk pregnancy designation means emotionally

A high-risk pregnancy designation — whether it follows an unexpected test result, a maternal health condition, a complication that develops during the pregnancy, or a prior obstetric history — reorganizes the emotional experience of pregnancy in ways that extend well beyond the medical management it requires.

Research comparing women with high-risk pregnancies to those with uncomplicated pregnancies consistently finds significantly elevated rates of anxiety, depression, and guilt in the high-risk group. A 2024 study found that women diagnosed with high-risk pregnancies reported higher levels of anxiety, depression, and guilt compared to a control group of women with healthy pregnancies — findings that have been replicated across settings and populations.

What the numbers describe, in clinical terms, is an experience that many people navigating high-risk pregnancies will recognize: a pregnancy that has ceased to feel like a period of ordinary anticipation and become instead a sustained exercise in managing fear, monitoring for signs of change, and trying to hold hope and dread at the same time. The conditions that generate a high-risk designation are diverse — they include preeclampsia, gestational diabetes, fetal growth restriction, placenta previa, preterm labor, multiple gestation, fetal anomalies, and many others — but their psychological impact shares important features.

Common emotional experiences in high-risk pregnancy include:

  • A sense that the pregnancy can no longer be trusted to proceed without vigilance — that normal anticipation is not accessible
  • Guilt, which can attach to the condition itself (as if the pregnant person caused it) or to any moment of not being sufficiently careful, worried, or compliant
  • Grief for the uncomplicated pregnancy that was anticipated, and that this pregnancy has not turned out to be
  • Exhaustion from the sustained emotional and cognitive labor of managing fear over the weeks or months of the pregnancy
  • A changed relationship with the medical system — more appointments, more monitoring, more opportunities to receive concerning information — which can itself become a source of anticipatory anxiety
  • Isolation from other pregnant people whose pregnancies are unfolding differently, and from a culture of pregnancy that rarely acknowledges the complexity of a high-risk designation

A high-risk designation does not mean that the pregnancy will not result in a healthy baby, and it does not mean that the pregnant person has done anything wrong. What it does mean is that they are managing a significantly elevated level of psychological stress, often without adequate support for that specific experience.

Chronic uncertainty and what it does to the nervous system

One of the most consistent features of high-risk pregnancy and ongoing prenatal surveillance is sustained, unresolvable uncertainty. The anxiety of a high-risk pregnancy often has no natural endpoint. The next appointment brings either reassurance that does not fully resolve the underlying concern or new information that generates its own anxiety. The pregnancy unfolds in a state of sustained not-knowing that is genuinely difficult to tolerate.

What chronic uncertainty in pregnancy can look like:

  • Seeking frequent reassurance from providers — more appointments, more calls, more requests for information — without finding that the reassurance helps for long
  • Difficulty making any plans or commitments that extend beyond the immediate future, because the future feels too contingent
  • Hypervigilance to physical symptoms — monitoring for signs that something is changing, worsening, or wrong
  • Difficulty sleeping, concentrating, or sustaining attention on anything unrelated to the pregnancy
  • A foreshortened sense of the future — an inability to picture what life will look like after the pregnancy, because the outcome is not yet known
  • Emotional exhaustion from the sustained effort of managing fear over an extended period

It is important to name that these responses are not irrational. They are proportionate to a genuinely uncertain situation. But they can also become their own source of suffering, and they are amenable to support. The goal of therapy in this context is not to eliminate uncertainty — which is not possible — but to develop a different relationship with it: one in which uncertainty can be acknowledged and held without being all-consuming.

How partners experience prenatal testing and high-risk pregnancy

Partners carry their own version of the anxiety, fear, and uncertainty that accompanies prenatal testing and high-risk pregnancy, and their experience often receives less explicit acknowledgment than that of the pregnant person. Research on partners following high-risk prenatal findings consistently documents high levels of anxiety and guilt, alongside the complexity of managing their own emotional experience while trying to support the pregnant person.

For partners, prenatal testing and high-risk pregnancy may involve:

  • Their own fear about the outcomes, which may feel less permissible to express given the more visible weight being carried by the pregnant person
  • Uncertainty about how to be helpful — when to offer information, when to sit with fear rather than try to resolve it, and how to stay present when they themselves are frightened
  • Frustration with a medical system that often addresses communication primarily to the pregnant person, leaving partners without a clear role or adequate information
  • Their own grief response to an unexpected finding — which may unfold differently or on a different timeline than the pregnant person's
  • Decision-making stress, particularly if the couple is navigating a difficult or contested choice about how to proceed

Partners are not only support people. They are individuals with their own emotional experience of a shared situation, and that experience deserves its own space and support. Individual therapy for partners during high-risk pregnancy is not a diversion of resources from the pregnant person — it is what makes sustained, genuine support possible.

What others often say — and what actually helps

People navigating high-risk pregnancy or unexpected prenatal findings are often on the receiving end of well-intentioned comments that, despite their intent, fail to acknowledge the emotional reality of the situation or add pressure to feel differently than they do.

Common comments that can deepen distress include:

  • "Try not to worry — stress isn't good for the baby."
  • "At least they caught it early."
  • "Modern medicine can do so much — I'm sure everything will be fine."
  • "You just have to stay positive."
  • "Other people go through this and it turns out okay."
  • "At least you know what you're dealing with now."

These responses often reflect others' discomfort with uncertainty and distress. They move quickly toward reassurance without first making room for the fear, grief, or anger that is actually present. The implicit message in many of them — that the right response is optimism and that worry is itself a problem — can make it harder for a person to acknowledge how they are actually feeling and to seek the support they need.

What is more genuinely helpful is usually simpler: acknowledgment of how hard this is, willingness to sit with the uncertainty alongside the person rather than trying to resolve it, and practical offers of help that do not require the person to manage someone else's discomfort alongside their own. The absence of easy reassurance is not a failure of support. It is an honest response to a situation that does not have easy answers.

What therapy for prenatal testing anxiety and high-risk pregnancy can look like

Therapy during prenatal testing, following an unexpected finding, or throughout a high-risk pregnancy is not about eliminating anxiety or achieving a particular emotional state. The uncertainty is real; the anxiety is proportionate; the stakes are high. What therapy can offer is a space in which the full weight of this experience is acknowledged, a set of skills for navigating sustained uncertainty, and support for the decision-making that may be required.

In my work with clients navigating prenatal testing and high-risk pregnancy, therapy often involves:

  • Making space for the grief, fear, anxiety, anger, and disorientation that follow an unexpected finding — without moving too quickly toward problem-solving or reassurance
  • Working directly with uncertainty: understanding what it is, where it shows up in this person's experience, and developing a more flexible relationship with ambiguity
  • Identifying the difference between productive information-gathering and reassurance-seeking that temporarily reduces anxiety without addressing its source
  • Preparing for specific high-anxiety moments — upcoming scans, results appointments, conversations with specialists — with strategies for the waiting period, for receiving information, and for the aftermath
  • Supporting decision-making and helping the client identify what they actually value and need in order to make a choice that feels integrated with who they are
  • Addressing guilt and self-blame directly, including examining the attributions that attach to a pregnancy complication or anomaly and where they come from
  • Connecting this pregnancy's distress to broader experiences — prior loss, medical anxiety, prior trauma — that may be shaping how this experience is being processed
  • Building a coping plan for the specific procedures and appointments the pregnancy requires, drawing on evidence-based strategies for managing procedural anxiety

I draw on Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) and cognitive behavioral approaches in this work. ACT is particularly well-suited to prenatal testing and high-risk pregnancy because it does not require the elimination of fear or the achievement of positivity as a precondition for functioning — it builds the capacity to move toward what matters even in the presence of significant uncertainty, and to hold difficult thoughts and feelings with more flexibility and less struggle. CBT-informed approaches, including work on intolerance of uncertainty, target specific patterns of anxious thinking and behavior that can sustain and amplify distress beyond what the situation itself requires.

When to seek support

Support is appropriate whenever the emotional weight of prenatal testing or high-risk pregnancy is affecting daily functioning, relationships, sleep, or the capacity to engage with medical care. You do not need to have received a specific diagnosis. You do not need to be at a breaking point. The experience of sustained fear and uncertainty during pregnancy is itself a sufficient reason to seek support from a clinician with experience in perinatal mental health.

You do not need to be in crisis to reach out. Many people find that beginning therapy before distress becomes acute — in the early days after an unexpected finding, or at the beginning of a high-risk designation — allows for the most sustained and effective support.

If any of this resonates, I would be glad to connect. You can reach me through my contact form or at contact@drjesscoleman.com.

Telehealth therapy during prenatal testing and high-risk pregnancy

I provide telehealth therapy to adults in North Carolina, California, and 40+ PSYPACT states. I specialize in reproductive and perinatal mental health, including anxiety related to prenatal testing, unexpected or uncertain findings, and high-risk pregnancy. I also work with clients preparing for and processing specific procedures — including amniocentesis, diagnostic ultrasounds, and maternal-fetal medicine appointments — that carry significant emotional weight. Telehealth allows you to access specialized support from wherever you are, without adding another clinical environment to an already appointment-heavy period of care. You can reach me through the contact form on this site or by emailing contact@drjesscoleman.com.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it normal to feel anxious before and after prenatal testing even when I have no reason to think anything is wrong?

Yes. Anxiety before, during, and after prenatal testing is common even when there are no specific risk factors and no prior indication of concern. Prenatal testing asks people to sit with the possibility of an outcome they do not want, and the nervous system responds to that possibility with activation regardless of how statistically likely the unwanted outcome actually is. Research finds that anxiety levels are elevated in pregnant people awaiting prenatal test results across a wide range of risk profiles — not only in those whose results ultimately come back concerning. The anxiety is a response to uncertainty, not a signal that something is wrong.

I received an unexpected prenatal result and I can't stop thinking about worst-case scenarios. Is this normal?

Yes, and it is a well-documented response to an unexpected prenatal finding. Research consistently describes a shock response following unexpected results, followed by a period of intrusive worry, difficulty absorbing new information, and preoccupation with worst-case outcomes. This is the nervous system's response to information that has restructured the emotional landscape of the pregnancy in a way it has not yet integrated. It does not mean that the worst-case outcome is likely, and it is not a sign that something is wrong with how you are responding. It is, however, a signal that you deserve support — both informational and emotional — that can help you begin to integrate what you have learned.

My pregnancy has been designated high-risk. Does that mean something is definitely wrong?

Not necessarily. A high-risk designation reflects an elevated level of monitoring and clinical attention — it indicates that additional care and surveillance are warranted, not that a poor outcome is certain. Many pregnancies designated as high-risk result in healthy babies and healthy birthing parents. That said, the emotional reality of a high-risk designation is significant regardless of the ultimate outcome: research consistently finds elevated rates of anxiety, depression, and guilt in people navigating high-risk pregnancies compared to those with uncomplicated pregnancies. The emotional weight is real, it deserves support, and it is not resolved by reassurance that outcomes are often good.

I'm facing a difficult decision after a prenatal finding and I don't know how to think about it. Can therapy help?

Yes. Therapy can be particularly valuable in the period following an unexpected finding when significant decisions need to be made. One of the most useful things a therapist can offer in this context is help separating the informational from the emotional — supporting you in identifying what you actually need to know, what you already know, what your values are, and what kind of support would help you make a decision that feels integrated with who you are. Decisions of this kind are almost never simply logical problems to be solved; they involve grief, fear, values, and relational dimensions that all deserve attention. Therapy is not directive, and it does not advocate for any particular decision. It helps create the conditions in which a considered, self-consistent choice becomes more possible.

I'm not in a high-risk pregnancy, but I have severe anxiety every time I have a prenatal appointment. Is that enough of a reason to seek therapy?

Yes. Significant anxiety around prenatal appointments, regardless of the clinical risk profile of the pregnancy, is a meaningful source of suffering and a legitimate reason to seek support. Evidence-based coping skills for procedural and medical anxiety can meaningfully reduce distress before and during appointments, and therapy can address the broader anxiety and patterns of worry that are driving the experience. You do not need a high-risk designation, a specific finding, or a particular level of distress to deserve support.

Further Reading

Jess Coleman, Ph.D.
Next

Pregnancy After Loss: Anxiety, Hope, and the Complicated Path Forward